What Is Mushroom Compost and Why Use It (2024)

Unlike the name suggests, mushroom compost does not a contain any mushrooms—it is a by-product from mushroom farming; the growth medium of mushrooms that is removed after the mushrooms are harvested. The more apt name for it is mushroom soil.

Just like regular compost, mushroom compost is often touted as black gold. It acts as both a plant fertilizer and soil amendment that can benefit your plants when used properly.

What Is Mushroom Compost and Why Use It (1)

How Mushroom Compost Is Made

When the substrate in which mushrooms are grown is no longer suitable for mushroom-growing, it is still valuable for gardeners.

Mushroom substrate contains hay, straw, poultry or horse manure, crop residue such as corn cobs and cocoa shells. The exact composition of the growth substrate varies from grower to grower. The substrate is composted for about 30 days at a temperature of 160 degrees F to kill any weed seeds, pests, or disease pathogens. Additionally,it is steam-pasteurized at about 140 degrees F to kill any pests and pathogens that could cause surface diseases. Then the medium is inoculated with mushroom spawn, or mycelium, and covered with a layer of sphagnum moss and ground limestone to support the mushroom growth.

After mushrooms have been harvested for about three to four weeks, the medium’s ability to sustain mushroom growth is exhausted and it is replaced with fresh mushroom soil for a new batch of
mushrooms. The substrate is then sold as bags or bulk, often labelled as SMC (Spent Mushroom Compost) or SMS (Spent Mushroom Substrate).

The Pros and Cons of Mushroom Compost

Mushroom compost is not an cure-all for your garden soil. It has benefits and disadvantages.

ProsCons
Supplies macronutrients (nitrogen, phosphorous, potassium), and micronutrients (calcium, magnesium, iron) to the soilNutrient composition varies depending on the materials used
High in organic matter, which increases the water-holding capacity of the soil, boosts the activity of beneficial soil microbesHigh in soluble salts and other nutrients that can kill germinating seeds, harm young seedlings, and cause damage to salt-sensitive plants
Improves the structure of clay and compacted soils, which increases drainage
Suitable for most garden plants, both edibles and ornamentalsPricy and not readily available
High levels of calcium which benefits some crops, such as tomatoesHigh calcium content can increase the soil pH and make it too alkaline

Mushroom Compost vs. Regular Compost

Mushroom compost and regular compost are not interchangeable due to key differences between the two.

All compost varies in composition, unlike commercial fertilizer, where the label gives a detailed analysis of the nutrients. Mushroom compost has already been used as a growing medium which means it generally contains less nitrogen than regular compost. It may be a good choice for soil already rich in nitrogen since excess nitrogen can lead to overgrowth of foliage and stunted roots.

Mushroom soil also contains more calcium than regular compost due to the addition of chalk. Plants like tomatoes do well in a calcium-rich soil which helps tamp down blossom-end rot. However, calcium increases the soil pH level which is problematic for plants like blueberries that need acidic soil.

Mushroom Compost vs. Manure

Mushroom compost and manure are two different soil amendments, not only in their composition but also in their use.

Mushroom compost contains a wide range of organic materials, including horse manure, which have undergone a sanitization process before the mixture is used for growing mushrooms. It is less dense and lighter than manure and ready to be spread in the garden. Manure, on the other hand, regardless of the type (cow, horse, or poultry), only contains animal dung and straw or sawdust from the animal’s bedding or litter areas. Fresh manure is very high in nitrogen and needs to mature before being used, otherwise it will burn the plants.

Fresh mushroom compost has an average of 6.6 so it falls right into the ideal pH range for most crops between 6.0 and 7.0. Manure has a higher pH (above 7.0) and makes soil more alkaline.

Tip

If you are an organic gardener and want to make sure the mushroom source is also fully organic, select mushroom compost from certified organic mushroom farms that practice organic fertilization, pest, and fungal disease management.

When and How to Use Mushroom Compost

Most mushroom compost sold in the trade has been aged or cured but if you happen to buy mushroom compost that is still fresh, it needs curing before you add it to your soil. Purchase fresh material in fall, winter, or early spring to give it ample time to sit and cure before planting or spreading it around plants. Rain and snowfall leach excess salts from the substrate and the already low pesticide residue that might be in the substrate from the mushroom growing has time to decompose.

What Is Mushroom Compost and Why Use It (2)

Aged, cured mushroom compost can be applied any time in the spring or summer. Application is most effective when the soil is fairly dry, which avoids compacting the soil while tilling in amendments.

Aged mushroom compost, either worked into the soil or spread around the base as mulch, can be added to a wide range of plants, including:

  • Lawns, also as a top-dressing for newly seeded lawns
  • Vegetable gardens
  • Orchards
  • Perennials, trees, and shrubs
  • Container plants

For flower beds and vegetable gardens, evenly spread one to three inches of mushroom compost over the surface and till it into the top six inches of soil. For container plants, mix about one quarter volume of aged mushroom compost with three-quarters of potting medium.

The 8 Best Composters of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

FAQ

  • What plants like mushroom compost?

    Most garden crops benefits from mushroom compost as a soil amendment, especially plants that tolerate higher salt content and benefit from additional calcium, such as tomatoes. Make sure to only use well-aged mushroom soil around rhododendrons, azaleas, camellias, and other members of the Heath family, (Ericaceae) because the high salt content can harm the plants.

  • Can you plant directly in mushroom compost?

    You should not plant in mushroom compost as the only growth medium but always work it into the soil. If you follow this rule, it depends whether you can plant directly in the amended soil. Tender seedlings and seeds are sensitive to the high salt levels in mushroom compost so it’s better to wait until the plants are established before working some mushroom soil into the soil around the plants.

  • Can you use too much mushroom compost?

    As with all soil amendments, overdoing it is harmful. Don’t exceed the recommended amount of a 1- to 3-inch layer or three to nine cubic yards per 1,000 square feet.

The Spruce uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.

  1. What Is Mushroom Compost? Oregon State University Extension Service.

  2. Does Adding Manure Lower or Raise Soil pH? University of Florida.

  3. Spent Mushroom Substrate. Penn State Extension.

  4. Mushroom Compost FAQ. American Mushroom Institute.

What Is Mushroom Compost and Why Use It (2024)

FAQs

What Is Mushroom Compost and Why Use It? ›

Mushroom compost has a high organic content and can be used as an improver in garden environment. Depending on the formulation, the NPK of the compost is 1-0.2-1.3, although the nitrogen content may be as high as 2%.

What is the purpose of mushroom compost? ›

What does mushroom compost do? When used as an amendment, it provides a readily-available source of organic material to soil, which increases water capacity, microbial activity, and soil temperature. It also improves soil structure and amends clay-like soils over time.

What is the best way to use mushroom compost? ›

Use mushroom compost as a general mulch, spreading a 5cm layer on flower beds, herbaceous and shrub borders and around young trees and specimen shrubs. Mushroom compost can also be used to improve waterlogged or clay soils as well as light, free-draining soils.

What are the benefits of spent mushroom compost? ›

As a soil improver: Spent mushroom compost contains a high nitrogen and chalk content rich in calcium and magnesium, which creates liming to increase the soil's pH level.

What nutrients does mushroom compost provide? ›

Also, mushroom compost contains an average of 0.67 percent phosphate (phosphorous) and 1.24 percent potash (potassium), as well as other plant nutrients such as calcium (2.29 percent) magnesium (0.35 percent) and iron (1.07 percent).

What are the disadvantages of mushroom compost? ›

The Pros and Cons of Mushroom Compost
ProsCons
High in organic matter, which increases the water-holding capacity of the soil, boosts the activity of beneficial soil microbesHigh in soluble salts and other nutrients that can kill germinating seeds, harm young seedlings, and cause damage to salt-sensitive plants
4 more rows
Feb 27, 2024

What plants do not like mushroom compost? ›

Mushroom compost is also high in salt, which can be problematic for some plants such as blueberries, camellias, rhododendrons and azaleas. These soluble salts along with other nutrients in fresh mushroom compost are too concentrated to germinate seeds or plant young seedlings.

When should you not use mushroom compost? ›

Mushroom compost use should be avoided where ericaceous plants such as rhododendrons, camellias, azaleas and heathers are being grown, as these plants need acidic growing conditions and are chalk-hating.

Can you use too much mushroom compost? ›

Mushroom compost can supply nutrients and increase water-holding capacity of the soil. But mushroom compost can also be too much of a good thing for seeds, seedlings and young plants.

Which is better, mushroom compost or manure? ›

If you have a lot of acid-loving plants like blueberries, azaleas, and rhododendrons, cow manure may be better. If the idea of having to compost manure turns you off, then perhaps mushroom compost may be more your speed. Whichever you choose, both are solid choices!

Can you plant directly in mushroom compost? ›

How to Use Mushroom Compost. Mushroom compost needs to be mixed with soil and should not be used alone to grow plants in. If you are amending your soil with neat mushroom compost, you should mix it in at a ratio of one part compost to two parts soil.

How long does mushroom compost last? ›

You may use spent compost weathered for 6 months or longer in all gardens and with most plants. Obtaining mushroom compost in the fall and winter, allowing it to weather will make it ready to use in a garden the following spring. Spring and summer are the best time to use weathered material as a mulch.

Is mushroom compost better than worm castings? ›

To summarize, both products are a good supply of organic matter. Plants grown in good soil-applied to either of these products are healthy. However, to answer the question of mushroom compost vs worm castings, mushroom compost is the best choice due to its less time-consuming nature.

What is the best use of mushroom compost? ›

Mushroom compost can be an effective mulch product when fresh, as weed seeds find it more difficult to take root in. As it breaks down further, it should be worked into the soil. If you're doing a no-till garden, you can simply overlay the mulch layers with other soil layers.

Is mushroom compost good for potatoes? ›

Add about two to three inches of compost in the trench. I use Espoma's Organic Mushroom Compost. This way, when potatoes are first planted, they'll feel like they're in 100 percent compost, which will give them a great start.

Which is better leaf or mushroom compost? ›

Mushroom soil typically has more nutrient content (particularly nitrogen) than leaf compost. When preparing new beds, I think it's best to go moderate with amendments. A maximum of about one-third of either of these to two-thirds of your soil is good.

Is mushroom compost better than regular compost? ›

As for nutrient content, that'll vary somewhat depending on exactly what went into the compost and mushroom soil. Mushroom soil typically has more nutrient content (particularly nitrogen) than leaf compost.

What is better, cow manure or mushroom compost? ›

Richer source of organic nutrients: manure is a source of many nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. In fact, most manures may contain slightly more of these three nutrients than mushroom manure.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rubie Ullrich

Last Updated:

Views: 6174

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (72 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rubie Ullrich

Birthday: 1998-02-02

Address: 743 Stoltenberg Center, Genovevaville, NJ 59925-3119

Phone: +2202978377583

Job: Administration Engineer

Hobby: Surfing, Sailing, Listening to music, Web surfing, Kitesurfing, Geocaching, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Rubie Ullrich, I am a enthusiastic, perfect, tender, vivacious, talented, famous, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.