Growing In Compost Without Soil: Facts On Planting In Pure Compost (2024)

Compost is an extremely popular and useful soil amendment that most gardeners can’t go without. Perfect for adding nutrients and breaking up heavy soil, it’s often referred to as black gold. So if it’s so good for your garden, why use soil at all? What’s to stop you from growing plants in pure compost? Keep reading to learn more about the wisdom of vegetable growing in compost without soil.

Can Plants Grow in Compost Only?

Can plants grow in compost only? Not nearly as well as you’d think. Compost is an irreplaceable soil amendment, but that’s just what it is - an amendment. Some of the essentials in compost are only good in small amounts. Too much of a good thing can lead to problems, such as ammonia toxicity and excessive salinity.

And while compost is rich in some nutrients and minerals, it’s surprisingly lacking in others. Much as it might go against your gut instinct, planting in pure compost could possibly result in weak or even dead plants.

Growing Plants in Pure Compost

Growing plants in pure compost can cause problems with water retention and stability as well. When mixed with topsoil, compost works wonders with water, as it allows good drainage through heavy soil while it retains water in sandy soil. Used on its own, however, compost drains quickly and promptly dries out.

Lighter than most soils, it can’t provide the stability necessary for strong root systems. It also compacts over time, which is especially bad for containers that won’t be nearly as full a few weeks after you plant in them. So while it may be tempting, planting in pure compost is not a good idea.

That’s not to say you shouldn’t plant in compost at all. Just an inch or two of good compost mixed with your existing topsoil is all your plants need.

Gardening tips, videos, info and more delivered right to your inbox!

Sign up for the Gardening Know How newsletter today and receive a free download of our most popular eBook "How to Grow Delicious Tomatoes."

Growing In Compost Without Soil: Facts On Planting In Pure Compost (2024)

FAQs

Growing In Compost Without Soil: Facts On Planting In Pure Compost? ›

Growing plants in pure compost can cause problems with water retention and stability as well. When mixed with topsoil, compost works wonders with water, as it allows good drainage through heavy soil while it retains water in sandy soil. Used on its own, however, compost drains quickly and promptly dries out.

Can you grow plants in pure compost? ›

Compost is one of the best garden amendments available. You can plant in straight compost, but I suggest incorporating it into your sandy garden soil or mixing it with other additives if you want to use it for container plantings.

Can you plant straight into homemade compost? ›

Using Compost in your garden

Compost also conditions soil, improves moisture retention, increases earthworm activity and improves fertiliser use by plants. For best results compost should be dug into the soil. Don't plant directly into compost as this can burn plant roots.

Can you grow grass in pure compost? ›

A sim- ple 1” application of compost will help in the germination of grass seeds and improve overall soil health in the process. Why: Compost is made up of decomposed organic matter that promotes better soil health with the replenishment of texture and microbes.

How can a plant grow without soil? ›

There are four methods of growing plants without soil-water culture, sand culture, gravel culture, and adsorbed-nutrient technique.

Can I use compost instead of potting soil? ›

Yes, you can use compost instead of potting soil. Doing so will boost the growth of your plants and help them grow strong. However, I'd strongly recommend mixing both. This way, your plants will receive the benefits of both compost and potting soil without losing out on nutrients, water retention and support.

Is compost enough for plants? ›

Adding compost increases the activity of soil organisms. They help to provide nutrients to your plants over time. Compost may not replace fertilizer. Lawns, vegetables and fruiting trees and shrubs often need additional fertilizer to thrive.

Can you grow tomatoes in compost only? ›

Tomatoes are one crop that has been known to grow rather well in pure compost. Many home gardeners have reported volunteer tomato plants that reared up out of their compost piles after tomatoes with seeds were tossed into the pile.

Can I transplant directly into compost? ›

Planting directly into compost is fine as long as it is well finished compost. Many no-till gardeners put just compost down in between growing seasons and plant directly into it.

Can I fill a raised bed with just compost? ›

It is possible to fill a raised bed with just compost, however it is not recommended. It does have good levels of organic matter, but is not a complete soil and needs to be part of a blend.

Does grass grow better in compost or topsoil? ›

If you're trying to grow a thick, lush carpet of grass, both topsoil and compost can be effective. Either one can be used to address bald spots in your lawn, by adding two to three inches' worth of topsoil or compost to the area and incorporating it into the existing soil to encourage grass growth over time.

What compost is best for growing grass? ›

If you're looking to grow new grass seeds or lay new lawn turf, you should consider adding a layer of mushroom compost to enhance its growth.

How long can a plant live without soil? ›

Most dormant plants can survive for months with bare roots. The issue is with a plant that is not dormant and it's cells are involved with photosynthesis and respiration. Allowing the roots to dry out can be fatal within hours depending on the size, temperature, sun, and variety.

Can plants get nutrients for growth without soil? ›

A long time ago, plant researchers found out that you can get plants to grow perfectly fine without soil if you provide water and the mineral nutrition. That's the idea of hydroponics where we can grow plants in a soil-less environment. We're providing what they need: water and the minerals that allow them to grow.

What is it called when you plant without soil? ›

Hydroponics is a method of growing plants without soil. You can grow hydroponically all year long. Hydroponics uses less water than traditional soil-based systems. Hydroponic growing allows for faster growth and higher yields than traditional soil-based growing systems.

Can I use compost instead of garden soil? ›

Growing directly in compost is not usually recommended. Water retention and support may be lacking in a 100% compost growing medium. Mixing compost with topsoil or potting mixes provides all the benefits of compost and your garden soil or potting mixes. You can make your own compost or purchase it in bulk or bags.

Is compost too strong for plants? ›

Adding too much compost may be harmful, especially in vegetable gardens. You can apply too much compost at one time or over several years. Too much compost in soil stunts plant growth. It also may create water pollution.

Do plants grow faster in compost or soil? ›

The key conclusions of my 6 weeks study for 18 plants of 3 different types, are: The Composted plants registered the best growth in all the 3 categories. The Composted grew 37% more in length than the other two soil types and 26 % and 48% more leaves compared to the Ground and the Fertilized plants respectively.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 5795

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.