6 Thanksgiving turkey mistakes everybody makes (2024)

Unless you’re certain presidential candidates, it’s hard to argue with science.

Author J. Kenji López-Alt has spent hundreds of hours in the kitchen, testing recipes and methodology to discover the best way to cook pretty much everything.

His new book, “The Food Lab: Better Home Cooking Through Science,” tackles everything from steak to mac and cheese. And, as luck would have it, turkey.

“In the kitchen, having science on your side gives you more options and control over your finished dish,” he tells The Post.

Want to cook the perfect bird for Thanksgiving? Here, López-Alt tells you six things not to do.

Don’t butter your bird

Placing butter under the skin won’t make the meat juicier, though it might help the skin brown faster. However, butter is about 17 percent water, and it will make your bird splotchy, says López-Alt. Instead, rub the skin with vegetable oil before you roast.

Don’t brine

The salt in the brine will break down the protein in the turkey muscle and allow your bird to absorb 7 to 13 percent more moisture than an unbrined bird. However, that moisture is just plain flavorless water. “A brined turkey will be juicier, but it will taste more watery,” says López-Alt, who recommends dry brining. Rub the turkey all over with kosher salt and let it sit in the fridge for a night or two before it’s cooked. “It helps the turkey retain its own natural juices,” he says.

Don’t forget to rest

Allow your bird to sit after it comes out the oven so the juices can settle. When its internal temperature measures a few degrees below what it was when it came out of the oven, it’s ready to eat.

Don’t overcook it

The main Thanksgiving sin is, of course, dry meat. Remove the bird from the oven when the dark meat is 170 degrees and the white 150. “If you overcook it, anything you apply won’t have much effect,” López-Alt says.

Don’t keep your bird intact

“All birds have two types of muscles. There’s breast muscle that’s very rarely used. There’s not much fat or connective tissue, so it should be cooked to no more than 155 degrees,” López-Alt says. “Then you also have thighs and drumsticks. Those have connective tissue and fat, and need to be cooked to a higher temperature, more like 170 to 175 degrees. The problem is, you have this one bird and you’re trying to get two temperatures on it. How do you resolve that?” Spatchco*cking! Cut out the backbone (or have your butcher do it) so your turkey can be pressed flat. Cook it on a wire rack atop a baking sheet at 450 degrees for about 80 minutes. This method will allow the dark meat to finish cooking before the breast meat gets dry.

Don’t stuff

Loading up your bird can lead to dangerously undercooked stuffing. “I don’t recommend it. It’s too much of a hassle,” López-Alt says. Cook it separately on the side.

Two healthy sides to go with your turkey

Thanksgiving doesn’t just mean getting along with family members with different political views and football-team allegiances. You also have to make peace with everyone’s special diets — from your niece experimenting with veganism to a paleo-crazed brother. Here, two delicious recipes for those with (and without) dietary restrictions.

• Vegan: Sweet potatoes

With no added sugar or dairy, these yams are perfect for vegans or diabetics, but, says Cheryl Forberg, chef and nutritionist for “The Biggest Loser,” “it’s a great recipe for anyone.”

Make a pistachio butter by combining 1 cup unsalted pistachios, shelled and roasted, and 2 ½ tablespoons grapeseed oil in a food processor or blender. Process or blend until smooth and creamy. Set aside.

Preheat oven to 400 F. Place 2 pounds sweet potatoes, cleaned and trimmed, on a baking sheet and prick with a fork. Bake until very tender when a fork or knife is inserted, approximately 1 hour. Remove from oven. When cool enough to handle, cut in half, scoop out flesh and place in a food processor.

Add 2 tablespoons of the pistachio butter, 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract, 1 teaspoon smoked salt and ½ teaspoon ground allspice. Process until smooth. Transfer to ovenproof dish. Cover and refrigerate overnight (or for up to two days).

Bring to room temperature one hour before warming. Preheat oven to 300 F. Place casserole in oven and heat just until warmed through, approximately 25 minutes. Remove from oven and garnish with chopped pistachios. Serves 8.

Paleo: Cran-cherry sauce

“My paleo cran-cherry sauce is super popular because it’s the perfect balance of tangy and sweet, without the addition of refined sugar,” says Nom Nom Paleo blogger Michelle Tam, who has an app and a book of the same title. “By adding an equal amount of cherries and simmering the fruit in apple juice, I was able to counter the mouth-puckering tartness of the cranberries with some natural sweetness.”

Put 6 ounces frozen cranberries, 6 ounces frozen sweet cherries, ¾ cup apple juice, ½ teaspoon minced ginger and a pinch of salt in a saucepan and bring to a boil.

Simmer for 8 to 10 minutes, until fruit has broken down and sauce has thickened.

Add 1 or 2 tablespoons honey for extra sweetness.

Let cool. Sauce can be made a day ahead for even deeper flavors.

— Hailey Eber and Claudine Ko

6 Thanksgiving turkey mistakes everybody makes (2024)

FAQs

6 Thanksgiving turkey mistakes everybody makes? ›

Generously rub salt and pepper inside the cavity, along with whatever other herbs and spices you're using. You can also push seasoned butter or olive oil under the skin of the breast, and around the thighs. You can use your fingers, or push a thin silicone spatula under the skin to separate it from the meat.

Should I rub my turkey with butter or oil? ›

Generously rub salt and pepper inside the cavity, along with whatever other herbs and spices you're using. You can also push seasoned butter or olive oil under the skin of the breast, and around the thighs. You can use your fingers, or push a thin silicone spatula under the skin to separate it from the meat.

Does putting butter under turkey skin help? ›

Impart rich flavor and add moisture to your Thanksgiving turkey by adding a layer of butter under the skin before roasting. Learn how to do this simple (but genius) technique for a delicious Thanksgiving turkey.

What not to do when cooking turkey? ›

Either method you choose, just make sure to thaw your turkey completely, so it cooks thoroughly.
  1. Mistake 2: Rinsing the Turkey. ...
  2. Mistake 3: Skipped the Seasoning. ...
  3. Mistake 4: Stuffing the Bird. ...
  4. Mistake 5: Forgot the Flavor. ...
  5. Mistake 6: Drying out Your Bird. ...
  6. Mistake 7: Guessing the Temperature. ...
  7. Mistake 8: Cutting too Soon.

Do you cover your turkey with foil while cooking? ›

We've found that covering a turkey in foil yields much moister results than roasting it without foil, and we favor simply covering up the breast to even out cooking time. Some people swear that roasting a turkey breast-side down and flipping it halfway through achieves the same results as a foil covered breast.

Do you put water in the bottom of the roasting pan for turkey? ›

"Often, consumers will inquire about adding water to the bottom of their roasting pans. We do not recommend adding water to the bottom of the pan. Cooking a turkey with steam is a moist heat-cook method and is acceptable, sure, but is not the preferred method for cooking your turkey."

What should you season your turkey with? ›

Ingredients for Turkey Dry Brine Seasoning Mix

For the most traditional flavored turkey, we recommend the following for a 14- to 16-pound turkey: 3 tablespoons kosher salt (we use Diamond Crystal brand) 1 1/2 combined teaspoons dried herbs: thyme, sage, and rosemary. 3/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper.

Should I season turkey the night before? ›

Every piece of poultry and pork, plus thicker cuts of beef and lamb, and even meatier fillets of fish like swordfish and grouper get seasoned at least one day ahead, and sometimes more, with kosher salt.

Why is my butter not sticking to my turkey? ›

Why isn't the butter sticking to the turkey? The bird may be condensating or your butter may be too cold and firm. Make sure the turkey comes to room temperature for an hour and pat it with paper towels to remove moisture before you butter it.

Should I use salted or unsalted butter for my turkey? ›

While the oven preheats, you'll rub a whole stick of unsalted butter (important because there's already lots of salt from the dry brine) on the turkey's surface, under the skin, and, if there's any left, inside the cavity. This ensures juicy turkey meat and truly golden brown skin.

Why should you not wash a turkey before cooking? ›

Wash your hands, but not the turkey! Many consumers think that washing their turkey will remove bacteria and make it safer. However, it's virtually impossible to wash bacteria off the bird. Instead, juices that splash during washing can transfer bacteria onto the surfaces of your kitchen, other foods and utensils.

Should you take turkey out of the fridge before cooking? ›

Before it goes in the oven, the turkey should be at room temperature, so take it out of the fridge (1 hr for a whole turkey, or 30 mins for a cut) before cooking.

What to do if the turkey is done 2 hours early? ›

If your turkey is done several hours before your meal, let it rest. Then carve off the breast meat, the legs and the thighs and arrange them on a serving platter and cover with foil. Just before you're ready to serve, reheat the platter in the oven (about 20 minutes at 350°F).

Is it better to cook a turkey at 325 or 350? ›

Oven-Roasted Turkey

We recommend starting the turkey in a 425 degree oven for 30-45 minutes before tenting the pan with foil and lowering the temperature to 350 degrees until a meat thermometer reads 165 degrees when inserted into the thickest part of the bird.

How many minutes per pound to cook a turkey? ›

Calculate turkey cooking time and temperature. The simplest way to figure out turkey roasting times is to calculate 13 minutes per pound at 350°F for an unstuffed turkey (that's about 3 hours for a 12- to 14-lb. turkey), or 15 minutes per pound for a stuffed turkey.

How long should a 12 lb turkey rest? ›

As the roast turkey rests (30–60 minutes is ideal), the residual heat will continue to push the internal temperature up to the goal temperature, without going over. Rest your bird on a cutting board with a trough, or on a platter, to collect any runoff juices (save them for gravy).

Should I rub oil on my turkey before smoking? ›

If you dry brined the turkey, it may not need extra seasonings. You only need to coat it with oil before placing it on your smoker or grill.

Should I put rub on turkey the night before? ›

You can rub your Thanksgiving turkey with seasoning the night before to enhance its flavor. How do you get rub to stick to turkey? Pat the turkey dry. Apply a thin layer of oil or a binder.

How often should I butter my turkey? ›

How Often to Baste a Turkey. Most recipes will tell you to baste your turkey every thirty minutes. But our rule of thumb is actually every forty minutes, and here's why. You don't want to open the oven too many times, or else the whole bird will take much long to cook, and that's a huge inconvenience.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Manual Maggio

Last Updated:

Views: 5825

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Manual Maggio

Birthday: 1998-01-20

Address: 359 Kelvin Stream, Lake Eldonview, MT 33517-1242

Phone: +577037762465

Job: Product Hospitality Supervisor

Hobby: Gardening, Web surfing, Video gaming, Amateur radio, Flag Football, Reading, Table tennis

Introduction: My name is Manual Maggio, I am a thankful, tender, adventurous, delightful, fantastic, proud, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.